No Planned Obsolescence in Education

We are a nation of makers and consumers. And in this free market culture, value is king and the art of the bargain is most prized. It’s a conundrum: you get what you pay for, but no one wants to pay full price. In every transaction, let the buyer beware!

So let me ask you this. Would you sink money into a car without dashboard displays? Would you buy a house with no electrical wiring or plumbing? How about a mobile device with no wireless capability? Yes I know; ridiculous examples. But follow me here…

How about schools? Would you build facilities for learning today that are not conducive to the kinds of learning that children need to be successful tomorrow? How about buildings that are already over capacity before the doors open for the first day? How about building schools that account for all the bricks, mortar and furniture but treat technology as a one-shot-deal afterthought? Not so ridiculous, is it? Let’s take this a step further…

Image

What about instruction itself? Would taxpayers pay for a school program that only targets certain subjects? Would they send their children to schools where every decision is driven by norm-referenced achievement scores? Would any community support a public school education that did not include the arts, physical education and health? How about one-size-fits-all instruction that does not meet each learner at their current levels of development and ability? Not quite so far-fetched, is it?

Community by community, we make a lot of compromises when it comes to public education, usually in the name of saving dollars. You know, being good stewards of the public trust. It’s another conundrum: we talk the bottom line, but we spend more money on education than any other nation. And we cut corners everywhere.

My point? If we drive a hard bargain to buy a whole car, and we pay an independent inspector to ensure we buy a whole house, and we talk to lots of people before we invest in the right mobile device, why don’t we make very sure that we educate the whole child? I mean, we’re talking about our future here. I know cars and houses and mobile devices are all predestined for obsolescence. But when it comes to education, should we be looking at our children the same way?

Image

Education is not just human cognition. It’s about preparing children for their future as well-adjusted global citizens: mentally, emotionally, socially, physically and personally. They need to feel safe, healthy, supported, engaged and challenged. They need to feel and be connected to peers, teachers, staff, volunteers: the community as a whole. In my humble opinion, if all children felt connected within their communities, there would be a lot less disaffected, disenfranchised, destructive behavior making the news these days.

And educating the whole child is not cost intensive; it simply requires making shifts in the allocation of the resources we have, from our instructional priorities to the community agencies that support children and families. Integrate all of our community programs, people and services within the total school program. Of course, that means we’d have to iron out the kinds of contradictions in cultural priorities I’ve referenced herein.

As educators, we work to develop each child’s full potential; the whole child. Why should school districts, government agencies and society as a whole sustain a public institution that provides for anything less? It’s time to give up cultural contradicitons and the convenience of conundrums and make deliberate and strategic choices in the name of each child being educated as a whole child.  Children are not born obsolescent. They’re resilient, full of hopes and dreams and promise. We owe them nothing less.

Image

More than a century ago, Oscar Wilde famously observed, “Nowadays people know the price of everything and the value of nothing.” In an age of abundance, it’s time to shake off the resigned legacy of planned obsolescence, especially when it comes to our children and their future. Work, speak and act to support the whole child.

3 thoughts on “No Planned Obsolescence in Education

  1. Pingback: Eightoh9

Share your thinking!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s